Macdonald, A. J. (2013). Trickery, mockery and the Scottish way of war. Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 143. Vol 143, pp. 319-338.
 Title The title of the publication or report |
Trickery, mockery and the Scottish way of war | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Issue The name of the volume or issue |
Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 143 | ||
Series The series the publication or report is included in |
Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland | ||
Volume Volume number and part |
143 | ||
Number of Pages The number of pages in the publication or report |
434 | ||
Page Start/End The start and end page numbers. |
319 - 338 | ||
Downloads Any files associated with the publication or report that can be downloaded from the ADS |
|
||
Licence Type ADS, CC-BY 4.0 or CC-BY 4.0 NC. |
ADS Terms of Use and Access
|
||
Publication Type The type of publication - report, monograph, journal article or chapter from a book |
Journal | ||
Abstract The abstract describing the content of the publication or report |
Despite their prominence in later medieval Scottish narratives, the themes of trickery and mockery in the way war is presented have been subjected to little academic scrutiny. The current paper suggests that such scrutiny yields important insights. It is argued that trickery is given unusual weight in narrative sources to highlight Scottish ingenuity in defeating their more powerful English enemies in war. This is in turn reflective of actual Scottish military behaviour in which ruses of various sorts were practised, arguably more readily than in many other martial cultures. While this should not be taken to indicate that there was any significant Scottish departure from accepted ethics of war, it does highlight an element of distinctiveness both to the practice of war by the Scots and their martial self-perception. Mockery is often frequently deployed in sources depicting the Scots at war against the English. Often the intention is to subvert bombastic aristocratic attitudes, depicted as being typical of the English martial elite. This ties in with a representation of the Scots fighting a war that featured wide communal involvement and an earthier material culture. Again this is reflective of real reliance on a broad social spread participating in war, as necessitated by the realities of the Anglo-Scottish struggle and its significant imbalance of wealth and resources. By the time Hary's Wallace was composed, in the 1470s, suggestive shifts had taken place in how trickery and mockery in war were represented. There is in this text far less privileging of trickery, indicating a greater self-confidence among the Scots as the threat of English conquest became less sharp. Mockery has also changed in character, no longer seeking to puncture English aristocratic pretensions and instead offering a more generalised, and more brutal, attempt to highlight the complete moral depravity of the old enemy. | ||
Year of Publication The year the book, article or report was published |
2013 | ||
Locations Any locations covered by the publication or report. This is not the place the book or report was published. |
|
||
Source Where the record has come from or which dataset it was orginally included in. |
ADS Archive
(ADS Archive)
|
||
Relations Other resources which are relevant to this publication or report |
|
||
Created Date The date the record of the pubication was first entered |
18 Dec 2014 |
